# Evaluation — Attempt 2

## Overall Verdict: PASS

## Overall Assessment
The polished forest/lemon/glass intake and identity-booth direction has been preserved while the production-critical parser and lifecycle faults from attempt 1 have been corrected. The implementation now provides a credible all-or-nothing bulk workflow: the first worksheet is relationship-resolved, untrusted archives and XML parts are bounded, temporary artifacts are cleaned deterministically, and repeated camera sessions reset cleanly.

## Scores
| Criterion | Score | Status | Weight | Notes |
|-----------|-------|--------|--------|-------|
| Design Quality | 2/3 | PASS | HIGH | The guided import assistant and photo booth remain coherent with the established admin surface, with clear primary/secondary actions and calm explanatory hierarchy. |
| Originality | 2/3 | PASS | HIGH | Numbered intake cards, the bundle-mode chooser, and the compact camera booth remain specific to this workflow rather than generic form-library defaults. |
| Craft | 2/3 | PASS | MEDIUM | Responsive modal scrolling, mobile action stacking, accessible labels/status, 44px controls, focus containment, stream cleanup, and state reset are consistently executed. |
| Functionality | 2/3 | PASS | MEDIUM | Relationship-based XLSX selection, bounded streaming XML, archive policy, transaction/file rollback, permission/CSRF gates, real template output, and explicit camera lifecycle are all implemented and regression checks pass without database access. |

## What's Working Well
- `memberImportResolveSheet()` now reads the first sheet relationship from `xl/workbook.xml`, resolves it through `xl/_rels/workbook.xml.rels`, rejects external/non-worksheet relationships, normalizes the target, and constrains it to `xl/worksheets/*.xml`.
- XLSX processing now audits entry count, individual size, aggregate uncompressed size, compression ratio, encryption, and compression method before reading content. Worksheet/shared-string parsing uses `XMLReader` with network access and entity substitution disabled, plus row, cell, and shared-string caps.
- CSV limits are enforced inside the parser as well as at upload handling, so bundle and direct paths share the same 10 MB boundary.
- Bundle spreadsheets are restricted to one root-level `members.csv` or `members.xlsx`; the embedded sheet receives its own size check, all I/O return values are verified, and temporary files are deleted in `finally`, including parse-failure paths.
- Photo archives now reject unsupported non-image entries, encrypted/unreadable content, unsafe paths, excessive nesting, duplicate case-insensitive basenames, oversized images, high ratios, and excessive total photo bytes. Photos are limited to the documented root or `photos/` layout.
- All validation still completes before the transaction begins. The existing single transaction, sequential ID lock, randomized passwords and filenames, rollback, and written-file cleanup remain intact.
- Authentication, `members.create`, POST handling, and CSRF remain enforced by the endpoint rather than only by the interface.
- The template endpoint still emits the exact ten required headings with a UTF-8 BOM and Excel-friendly CSV response headers.
- Camera access remains explicit. Capture stops active tracks; reset now revokes object URLs, clears the canvas/blob/input, restores button visibility, and is invoked on retake, source switch, modal close, reset, and after submission. Unsupported/denied access falls back to upload with an accessible toast.
- The DB-free regression suite passes relationship-selected worksheet parsing, inline strings, missing-cell preservation, Excel serial conversion, invalid/duplicate headers, traversal, duplicate photo names, missing photos, compression bombs, encryption rejection, and camera fallback/cleanup presence. It explicitly does not load bootstrap or a database connection; the root verification also confirmed the member count remained unchanged.
- Fresh PHP lint passes for the parser and process endpoint. The local `php.ini` warning is an unrelated environment configuration warning and does not affect the clean lint result or passing suite.

## Issues Found

No release-blocking issues remain in the requested scope.

### Minor follow-up: Extend negative fixture coverage
- **What**: The implementation visibly enforces unsupported archive entries and `finally`-based bundle temp cleanup, but the regression script does not directly force those two failure branches.
- **Where**: `tests/member_import_regression.php`.
- **Why it matters**: Direct assertions would make future regressions in these already-correct branches easier to detect.
- **Suggested fix**: In a later maintenance pass, add one ZIP containing a root text file and one malformed bundle that throws after temp creation; assert rejection and verify no `jsow_sheet_*` artifact remains. This does not block the current release because the code paths are explicit and deterministic.

## Priority Fixes for Next Attempt
1. No required design or functionality fixes; the feature is ready within the reviewed scope.
2. Optionally expand regression coverage for unsupported non-image entries and exception-path temp-file deletion.
3. Optionally add a browser test with mocked `getUserMedia`/tracks for behavioral assertions beyond the current static camera checks.

## Should the next attempt REFINE or PIVOT?
REFINE only if additional automated coverage is desired. The interaction design and technical architecture are now sound; no pivot is warranted.
